DNN 7.4.2

I have a DNN page called "Login" where I have dropped the Account Login module. In site settings, I've set this Login page to be the main Login page for the entire site. Under Admin > Languages, I've set the EMAIL_PASSWORD_REMINDER_BODY.Text section to point the reset link to this Login page (instead of default.aspx as there's no login control there)

Link to reset password: http://[Portal:URL]/login.aspx?ctl=PasswordReset&resetToken=[Membership:PasswordResetToken]

Here's the problem: when a person clicks on this link, it brings them to the page but it's blank - the ctl="PasswordReset" doesn't show the form - it shows nothing.

I've configured this countless times on other websites (on other instances) and have never ran into this problem. Oddly, ctl=SendPassword does work properly.