It would be a bonus if the home page for registered users were different than the one for unregistered users. I currently have both pages combined where every module on it is available to either registered or unregistered users, but not both.

I tried to disallow registered users access to the home page, which fixed the menu, but now results in an access denied page when they visit the root of my site. (which is where the site icon links to)

I wish it were that easy.

Unfortunately unchecking "include in menu" also causes the page not to be the home page any more. The first page that is shown in the menu, always becomes the home page of the site.

When I visit localhost/ it now shows the second page of my site. And because that page is members only, unregistered users are greeted by the login page. :'(

To view the (intended) homepage I now need to visit localhost/Home.aspx. (which is the page configured as home page in the site settings)

Even worse: When I do include the home page in the menu (and set that page as the home page of the site), but place it as second item in the menu, the first item in the menu also becomes the homepage.

Conclusion: The first page in the menu is the home page of your site, no matter what. That can't be right can it?

(BTW, I'm using dnn 7.0.4)