Hi, we did check the database yesterday. Many of the pages have the same sort order number. In addition, when you change the sort order by dragging and dropping in the page manager it changes the number of both the page you moved and the one you moved it above. For instance, Home is sort order 99 and About Us is sort order 99. When I move Home above About Us the sort order changes to 102 and 105 respectively. Thus, another page with a sort order of 103 could appear between the two pages, causing the strangeness.
In addition, a site map for portal 3 on our server was generated last night, after we rearranged the pages. It is all messed up. You can see it here: http://www.fortlewis.edu/sitemap.aspx?portalid=3
You will see the child portal is /paa/ which is a portal dedicated to student programs but the pages after that are from the IT website.
So, we're homing in on the issue but still don't have a solution. What do we need to do? It is vital that we fix this soon because it is affecting our rank in google and the user experience on 160 mission critical websites.
Thanks for all your help.
Scott