Products

Solutions

Resources

Partners

Community

Blog

About

QA

Ideas Test

New Community Website

Ordinarily, you'd be at the right spot, but we've recently launched a brand new community website... For the community, by the community.

Yay... Take Me to the Community!

Welcome to the DNN Community Forums, your preferred source of online community support for all things related to DNN.
In order to participate you must be a registered DNNizen

HomeHomeOur CommunityOur CommunityGeneral Discuss...General Discuss...Is it just me or do consumers has a right to expectations about modules and skins they purchaseIs it just me or do consumers has a right to expectations about modules and skins they purchase
Previous
 
Next
New Post
3/19/2014 1:35 AM
 

 - and what should we as a community be doing about assisting them

In the past couple of weeks one of my long term clients decide they want to do a revamp on their site - and after some pondering found a skin they like.  

After purchasing the skin - which made lots of claims about fancy features like style pickers and the like - I was somewhat surprised to discover that the skin does not in any way attempt to style one of the most basic elements of the dnn style guide - being the dnnPrimaryAction style - you know the one that makes all those primary action buttons on just about every module ever developed show in the sites primary color.

It simply didn't do it - and when I initially talked to the developer - I was sent back a block of css that needed to be cut and pasted into a styles sheet and the color codes which i would need to work out for myself then manually updated to try and match what they were doing internally.

Now to be fair to the developer - when I went back and expressed some dismay that my clients don't have any clue how this would be done - and I doubt most other potential clients would either - they quickly replied that they would look at a better alternative - and promised a new build would be forthcoming.

In theory this is a good outcome - both for my client and future clients taking advantage of that skin.

But it got me to thinking about the impressions DNN makes on new users - and to a certain extent about the difference of expectations some of us with a lifetime of trials have come to I guess accept as normal - as opposed to what someone stumping up a couple of hundreds dollars for a module or skin may think they are getting.

My client - does not GET that I've just spent a number of hours which I cant really bill them for - getting the skin they have just purchased fixed.

And a new user - does not possibly even get that something is wrong - do they just assume - "well i guess that's how it works" or blame the skin or more likely maybe blame DNN for not being all that it could be.

In a circuitous way - i guess this all comes back to the idea of certification as well - how does DNN move forward into a internet where every one else is adhering to guides or design philosophies. 

I would be interested in hearing other peoples thoughts on this topic - and maybe any ideas on how the community can look at ways to improve our game.

Westa

 
New Post
3/19/2014 2:24 PM
 

Hi Wes - 

I would always push for a custom skin over buying the junk in the store. Do you really want unlimited color options? Do you need an infinite number of content panes? Probably not. Turning a precanned bootstrap 3 template into a skin shouldn't take much work. I would either build that time into your job, or partner up with someone who can do it for a reasonable price. There are a few firms out there that will take a pre-existing design (PSD) or theme and create a skin (I have no experience with them, but I know they exist). And if you need a custom designed skin, you may want to seek out a design firm with dnn experience...toot

 

 
New Post
3/19/2014 7:29 PM
 

I broadly agree with your points Wes, but the issue is more what to measure (if you ask 10 skin designers, I guarantee 10 different lists), and how to measure compliance.

You may recall, years ago we introduced a skin and module certification program to try to raise the quality bar overall, and allow new users to have a better guarantee of quality. This proved to be problematic as we had to price it so that it was feasible , and in the end the price meant we have limited audit time. As this was pre-DNN corp we were effectively doing it in our spare time and the revenue was being used to underwrite other things, and in the end the program finished. In a way I didn't miss it as I was losing a lot of nights/weekends doing security audits, but in another way it was good to catch these before products went on sale (at one point 1 in 3 modules were failing security, with some of the other measures having similarly poor results).

When we revisted this as dnn corp, we knew that an automated solution was the only feasible way forward, hence the EVS solution (http://www.dnnsoftware.com/community-...). However EVS is primarily useful for modules, as except for those with manifest files, skin's don't really "install"/"uninstall" (more unpack/delete). If there were a valid set of agree upon "rules" for skins I don't think the EVS team would be adverse to implementing them, but as I'm not a skinner I'm not a good person to suggest any -perhaps http://www.dnnsoftware.com/forums/for... would be a good place for a discussion.

Note: I know the store tries to manage this via reviews by sending out emails a period after a customer has bought something to encourage them to leave feedback - at least in this way the quality should rise. I believe they have plans for additional social elements to further crowd-source feedback, hopefully that will allow potential customers a better way to filter out lower quality releases.


Buy the new Professional DNN7: Open Source .NET CMS Platform book Amazon US
 
New Post
3/19/2014 9:15 PM
 

Don’t you love the client who’s armed with knowledge and that dangerous red button?  I can see the mix of client base you have and it’s hard to stop them from going to the store and getting completely bamboozled by fancy skins that are in fact bloat technology designed to give DotNetNuke a bad name.

I think Wes, it come down how you talk to your clients about what you provide.

I give my clients options – you have a template Walmart style skin and that the shopping centre there is filled with empty promises, or you can invest a little more and we can make it for you but given we’ve been developing DotNetNuke for a decade now, and primarily in the skin area as well as high level deployment, I’m quite upfront.

If your clients think they know better.. being armed and dangerous and wearing rose tinted glasses, it might be an opportunity to provide a service for them to charge them for researching for them, or telling them in a very clear manner – you buy you’re responsible and give them some tough love.

I don’t seem to have that problem with clients mainly because we can skin and we just tell people to find what they like and we’ll make it happen, so for them they feel we are the ones to go to for all things.

Sometimes it’s worth losing a couple of clients who become like a lead weight around your neck getting themselves into trouble and you always having to through the lifeline out but letting a few sink is like giving yourself wings… honestly it is.

Problems can be turned into opportunities and it could be a good time to let your restless customer base know that if they are thinking about an upgrade or enhancement on their site, that you’re the person to come to and use a few case studies to show what you've been up to.

I guess our model is slightly different, and we do not allow host access to any of our sites, except staff.  We do all the upgrades, skin and module installs, only when tested on our servers. Our clients do not have ftp or cpanel, nothing, we look after it all and while I've lost a few clients who want more control, let me tell you, I’ve gained more because I am insistent on the fact that 95% of the modules and skins on that store are overpriced, they under deliver, have lousy support, bounced emails from developers and for the life of me I don’t know how people just spent hundreds, if not thousands of dollars, on stuff they will never use.

And it’s not limited to DotNetNuke that’s for sure – the internet is littered with wasted money, wasted time, and insecure plugins for WordPress, so I guess the devil you know is better than the one you don’t. I’m not being critical or picking on DotNetNuke in particular, mainly the mentality of people with little knowledge who are quick to blame when things don’t work properly which if they had bothered to ask a few questions first then they would be in a better position.

Having said that – I feel we need to take the blame somewhat by not communicating our services better to our client base who come to use for solutions.

I have for the last few years, asked people who get into trouble how much they would like to pay me to get out of it.. because I spent about 8 years fixing up other people’s problems to the detriment of my own state of mind and ability to grow my business and when I started to use these couple words –

1 – the money approach -

.. sure I can fix it – would you like to book a 1 hour consultation – I take credit card or Paypal or direct deposit.

2 – the time approach -

… Yes I can fix it, how about you send me the files and I’ll see when I can get back to you, how’s not this week, not next week but the week after… then I revert to approach 1

3 – the ‘It’s me not you approach’

… I’d love to fix it but I’m neck deep in work with paying customers (get your wife to give you a few dollars and you’re not lying J) and revert to 2, and then 1.

4 – the NO approach

… that feels good – I use that when I really want to drop a client who has finally worn me down… actually I pack them up and tell them to go away. I have only had to use approach 4, 5 times in my who career, and it has been generally around those who don’t want to pay or feel that the minuscule amount they pay me for something entitles them to more than what I feel I’m worth, and often you will find these people do the rounds and I may have gone through steps 1,2 & 3 first.

And in the meantime, look at creating an environment where you can get back to customers and provide with a modest fee to spend a few hours on their site to go through what they’re up to.

I’m taking a more light-hearted approach because I feel your pain and the devil is in the details on how you interact with clients and get them to come in line with expectations of what you are offering them as a service.

I know you work with your client’s best interests at heart Wes. I read your passion and posts on the forums here, and it would transcend in how you look after clients, but sometimes – we need to draw a line and if they are an A client, then you have some wiggle room, but if they are a B or C client, then you need to look at what you think your time is worth.

http://xdg.co/1d1Hhh4  - do you know this man? 

Just my thoughts for a day.

Nina


Nina Meiers My Little Website
If it's on DNN, I fix, build, deploy, support,skin, host, design, consult, implement, integrate and done since 2003.
Who am I? Just a city chic, having a crack at organic berry farming.. and creating awesome websites.
 
New Post
3/19/2014 11:05 PM
 
From my own perspective - its really not a big issue - been around dnn so long that I know there is pretty much nothing that I cant fix in some way

- what I guess my thoughts were really looking more towards is the NEW END USERS - the people in theory arriving here everyday.

DNN advertising seems to popup all over the place and should at least in theory be generating traffic - but that's a different topic.

For them - its rarely about having a consultant in the background - be it me or you nina or any other dnn professional.

Its the new ones - arriving looking for a hosting solution - for whatever reason. They are looking open source - they want to try and do it themselves - cost is always a issue.

And while some will say oh - sure its a cheap skin or module - custom is the only way to go - that is really a broken concept.

While for some in the rarefied world of big corporate - may think $150 is cheap - for many sites - non profiles, small businesses, ma&pa, soho, that amount may represent a large part of the budget they have available to dip their toe in the CMS water. Seems to me it comes down to perspective in that case.

And sadly when they do have a bad experience - its rarely the skin or the module that they will tell other people was bad - its going to be DNN that is broken.

Had a meeting the other day regarding a possible site development - the client was an associate of a business partner - so less of an arms length discussion - easy one to be frank and open with.

Most of the conversation was spent hosing down - misconceptions about DNN - I've been around for a long time and even I had trouble seeing where some of them had come from.
Until the penny finally dropped - he actually knew someone that had tried to build a dnn site - and well lets just say it did not go well.

Once that was finally out on the table - it actually turned into a reasonably positive conversation - but it was interesting that the key observation he had come to the meeting with was - DNN is not ready for the real world - it might be ok for hackers - but its not suitable for real businesses. Things dont work the way they should - or at least imply that they do - and its prone to breaking all the time.

And at the heart of it all - it turned out was a set of purchases from what was likely back then snowcovered. A skin that put them in a straight jacket - and exploded not long after they started working with dnn when they upgraded the dnn core version. A shopping cart module they paid a lot of money for - in their mind - which never worked the way they needed.

Ironically - yes had that person being talking to me back then - the one trying to get dnn running for themselves - they may have had a much smoother experience - turns out I knew a whole lot about that particular cart and im guessing nina you could work out pretty quickly which one im talking about too --- and the issues they were also facing with a skin developer that rolled a custom menu provider that was well lets just say REALLY badly written and should never have been sold to anyone-

Which is all well and good - as a thought game - but for lots of people - that does sadly seem to be the experience -

http://forums.whirlpool.net.au/archiv... makes for some sobering reading - sure its like a feeding frenzy for linux fanbois - and a lot has changed in the core over the years - but this is the sort of things people still find on the first page of a google search for "is dotnetnuke any good" And http://dnnsucks.wordpress.com/2010/03... was also thrown up.

Cant help but feel - that while all the marketing around evoq may slowly be gaining traction with big corporate - there is little or no positive ground swell for the underlying engine - which is something we as a community need to maybe do more about.

Westa

Just me thinking out loud ...
 
Previous
 
Next
HomeHomeOur CommunityOur CommunityGeneral Discuss...General Discuss...Is it just me or do consumers has a right to expectations about modules and skins they purchaseIs it just me or do consumers has a right to expectations about modules and skins they purchase


These Forums are dedicated to discussion of DNN Platform and Evoq Solutions.

For the benefit of the community and to protect the integrity of the ecosystem, please observe the following posting guidelines:

  1. No Advertising. This includes promotion of commercial and non-commercial products or services which are not directly related to DNN.
  2. No vendor trolling / poaching. If someone posts about a vendor issue, allow the vendor or other customers to respond. Any post that looks like trolling / poaching will be removed.
  3. Discussion or promotion of DNN Platform product releases under a different brand name are strictly prohibited.
  4. No Flaming or Trolling.
  5. No Profanity, Racism, or Prejudice.
  6. Site Moderators have the final word on approving / removing a thread or post or comment.
  7. English language posting only, please.
What is Liquid Content?
Find Out
What is Liquid Content?
Find Out
What is Liquid Content?
Find Out