Hi, I'm having this strange problem, limit the fields our users can see see on their profiles, I want to hide (not delete) "telephone", "website" and "IM"

I unchecked the "Visible" option for each on the User Profile list and set their visibility to "Admin only", 

They do not appear logged in as Admin, but those 3 fields still appear on the user profile when I'm connected as a normal, non admin user.

Is there another option I'm not contemplating? Thanks!